By far one of the best Italian restaurants we have in Toledo! Food is always delicious, and menu is constantly changing with seasonal ingredients. Weekly specials are great, and if your lost in your decision on what to get they are always a good choice. Highly recommend trying there mussels, the sauce they use is so fresh and tasty. You literally have a large bowl of delicious soup once you've finished the mussels! We tried a new appetizer, some sort of mushroom dip and it was amazing! Both meals were delicious, the lasagna, which does have boiled eggs on top, a little different was great. The three meat pasta was also scrumptious. Highly recommend trying this place! Reservation only, small dining experience is awesome and very unique and personal.
Garry Post
-
April 10, 2024
Wonderful little Italian restaurant in a strip mall in Maumee. We were fortunate to catch live piano playing during our Tuesday evening dinner. Surprisingly good wine list for such an out of the way location. Good food, good service and good atmosphere.
Roger Kerner
-
December 11, 2024
Our first time here but definitely not the last! THE BEST AUTHENTIC Italian cuisine in the area hands down. Service was perfect. Tiramisu is to die for.
Heather R. Doom
-
February 29, 2024
Wonderful first meal at Senastiano’s! ! Hubby had chicken Alfredo with spinach, mushrooms, and black olives that was to die for! Salad was excellent too. I loved the lobster ravioli in lemon cream sauce. The wine was superb and our server Amber was attentive and friendly. Our new favorite Italian restaurant! 💗💗
Ryann
-
May 15, 2021
Incredible Italian food with a Sicilian spin. The lasagna, surprisingly enough, has whole eggs (not eggs mixed into ricotta) actually in the layers! Sounds simple but that amazed me. The richness in the tomatoes in the bruschetta sharply and deliciously contrasts the way they’re roasted. In the shrimp fontina, the sauce was rich with flavors of the sea and the pasta was cooked to perfection. I don’t hype up many places, but if you come through Toledo, you must check out Sebastiano’s. Cozy atmosphere with light music on Friday nights, an evening you can’t miss.
Our Address
4448 Heatherdowns Blvd, Toledo, OH 43614, USA
Claim Listing: Sebastiano’s Italiano
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
By far one of the best Italian restaurants we have in Toledo! Food is always delicious, and menu is constantly changing with seasonal ingredients. Weekly specials are great, and if your lost in your decision on what to get they are always a good choice. Highly recommend trying there mussels, the sauce they use is so fresh and tasty. You literally have a large bowl of delicious soup once you've finished the mussels! We tried a new appetizer, some sort of mushroom dip and it was amazing! Both meals were delicious, the lasagna, which does have boiled eggs on top, a little different was great. The three meat pasta was also scrumptious. Highly recommend trying this place! Reservation only, small dining experience is awesome and very unique and personal.
Wonderful little Italian restaurant in a strip mall in Maumee. We were fortunate to catch live piano playing during our Tuesday evening dinner. Surprisingly good wine list for such an out of the way location. Good food, good service and good atmosphere.
Our first time here but definitely not the last! THE BEST AUTHENTIC Italian cuisine in the area hands down. Service was perfect. Tiramisu is to die for.
Wonderful first meal at Senastiano’s! ! Hubby had chicken Alfredo with spinach, mushrooms, and black olives that was to die for! Salad was excellent too. I loved the lobster ravioli in lemon cream sauce. The wine was superb and our server Amber was attentive and friendly. Our new favorite Italian restaurant! 💗💗
Incredible Italian food with a Sicilian spin. The lasagna, surprisingly enough, has whole eggs (not eggs mixed into ricotta) actually in the layers! Sounds simple but that amazed me. The richness in the tomatoes in the bruschetta sharply and deliciously contrasts the way they’re roasted. In the shrimp fontina, the sauce was rich with flavors of the sea and the pasta was cooked to perfection. I don’t hype up many places, but if you come through Toledo, you must check out Sebastiano’s. Cozy atmosphere with light music on Friday nights, an evening you can’t miss.